Theater Review – November 1, 2025

TPTC’S FASCINATING “LOOKING OVER THE PRESIDENT’S SHOULDER” PROVIDES INSIGHTS INTO FOUR MEN WHO LED THIS COUNTRY

“Looking Over the President’s Shoulder”
The Phoenix Theatre Company, Hardes Theatre
Phoenix AZ

By Chris Curcio
Theater Critic

Taking an insightful look at how four different men handled their Presidential duties through the thoughtful eyes of The White House’s Chief Butler is the premise of “Looking Over the President’s Shoulder,” The Phoenix Theatre Company’s (TPTC) superb one-man show.

Gifted performer Kelcey Watson portrays Alonzo Fields, the Chief Butler who served for 21 years from 1931 to 1953 aiding Presidents Herbert Hoover, Franklin Delano Roosevelt, Harry Truman, and Dwight Eisenhower.  Fields did not want to be a servant because of the ramifications he learned from his grandfather who had been a slave.  Fields hoped to use his excellent voice to become a professional singer but circumstances required him to find an immediate position.  He impressed Herbert Hoover’s wife who hired Fields and he ran the President’s House with thoughtful dignity.

Based on Fields’ book, James Still’s play provides a multitude of behind-the-scenes looks at the four unique men Fields served.  Each ran The White House based on their backgrounds as they approached day-to-day tasks.  Fields also interacted with each First Lady and, like their husbands, each was distinctive.  Some of the Presidential pairs talked easily with Fields while others were more removed but all were respectful and appreciative.

While giving away the characteristics of each President would spoil the play, a few tidbits to entice theatergoers.  Truman’s staunch civil rights stand on equality is especially revealing.  Roosevelt’s fatigue but feeling he had to resolve World War II caused his death but suggests strongly why the Constitution limits future Presidents to two terms. Some unusual observations about Winston Churchill prove entertaining.

The production is blessed with Watson’s sharply defined performance as Fields.  Watson keeps the audience intrigued by the differences of what Fields saw in each of the men and their wives he served.  There are moments when Watson became too introspective so his dialogue couldn’t be understood.  There are also times when Watson telescoped his small memory lapses on dialogue.  As the performance continues, these issues will no doubt disappear.

Fields’ actions are guided flawlessly by director Chanel Bragg who keeps the play dynamic and an evolving testament to the importance of the staff serving the President.  The simple set has a few welcome tricks that also intensified the action and locale.  One serious complaint.  The theater was freezing on opening night with drafty breezes making the space uncomfortable.

“Looking Over the President’s Shoulder” provides a rich look at what goes on in the background as each President found his own way to guide the country.  It continues through December 14. To order tickets, call The Phoenix Theatre Company box office at 602-254-2151 or order tickets online at www.phoenixtheatre.com.

Grade: A